The THEOLOGY OF THE BODY & MEDIA LITERACY blog of Sr. Helena Raphael Burns, fsp #medianuns
March 29, 2018
March 20, 2018
March 11, 2018
MOVIES: "THE FRANKENSTEIN CHRONICLES" (NETFLIX)
(I often dub Netflix
series "films.")
"The Frankenstein Chronicles" is the Brits at the
top of their dramaturgical game, showing off. The FC is a fascinating, intelligent,
somewhat contemplative, sophisticated, nuanced, suspenseful, imaginative
examination of the first half of nineteenth-century Christian England (pre-Darwin!) where sickness, disease
and early death run rampant. Religion, superstition, the occult and science all
attempt their cures. But what everyone really wants, then as now, is
immortality, to live forever, to come back from the dead, to see our loved ones
again. Mary Shelley herself is a character: "Mightn't we break the laws of
God in order to see our loved ones again? What wouldn't you do to see your
loved ones again?" Um, that's not how we see our loved ones again. God wants us to see our loved ones again.
Love God and neighbor and we will see
our loved ones again. Only God can give, "take" and give life again.
INVASION OF THE
BODY-SNATCHERS
The world of yesteryear is so well created, the diction so
tight, the research of the times so in-depth ("science" is correctly
called "natural philosophy"), the acting so superb, the story and dramatization
engrossing. Sean Bean (extraordinary acting here--that man is so good at rich, manly
emoting when he understands the part) plays a tough lawman who is looking for a
body-snatcher who supplies bodies for Frankenstein-like experiments. Children
are also the body-snatcher's victims, which makes it all the more abhorrent.
The characters are deeply Christian. Christianity is simply assumed
and permeating the culture. And not stupid, superficial, naive, mean Christians
(as often portrayed in American cinema set in any time period, often anachronistically.
What do I mean? I mean Americans, in their often ahistorical and feverish
progressivism can find it hard to reach back in time and plumb a different
mentality. The portrayals of Christians [really caricatures] wind up looking
like Jerry Falwell is the representative of true Christianity of every time and
place). Not so in FC. FC's Christians are a mixed bag, a cross-section of
society itself: kind Christians; charitable Christians; wealthy, socially-conscious
Christians who care for the poor; Christians who are trying; Christians who are
struggling with faith; Christians who take up their cross; hypocritical Christians, or Christians who
just pay lip service to God because it's respectable to do so or there's really
no other worldview circulating to choose from.
NOBODY DOES IT BETTER
I really must commend those enigmatic Brits on this ability
they have to suspend all their current-day ethea, assumptions and prejudices
and totally enter a past world. This is also done in an astonishing way in
"Call the Midwife," a BBC series based on the true-life reminiscences
of a young nurse mid-wife working with Anglican nuns in the poor East End of
London in the 1950's--where most births were home births. The series is
extremely pro-life, wherein everyone is rooting for the baby and the Mom no
matter how dire the circumstances. Abortion is illegal and rarely even thought
of as an option. Abortion would be an affront to the hope of these hardscrabble
citizens of the realm who work hard and love hard for a better future for their
progeny. "Call the Midwife" is a deeply joyous celebration of human
life, human possibilities and human thriving in the midst of hardship. It is a
tribute to the human spirit and to the filmmakers who, even today, can re-imagine
such a beautiful, kindly, more human world. But I digress.
FC is filled with organic intrigue. Just so well performed. Lots
of bio-ethical questions that are only MORE pertinent today--now that we have
so much bio-tech.
Sean Bean's character is the equivalent of a modern day
detective (representing the magistrate's office), a haunted man who doggedly rescues
women and children almost as a kind of penance for having lost his own wife and
child (a baby girl) due to his "carelessness." (I never quite figured
out what his "carelessness" was. Perhaps passing on the syphilis from
which he suffers?) We also witness the creation of the modern day police force,
or "bobbies," in 1829, named for Robert Peel, the Home Secretary.
THE DARK NIGHT OF GOD
FC is definitely dark--figuratively and literally--poorly
lit (a huge peeve of mine) mostly by lanterns, and we can almost feel the grime
and dankness of the pre-Victorian city rising off the screen. There is a fair
amount of blood and dismemberment and throat-slashing. But not gratuitous in my
estimation. FC's core deals with life and death and the body, and it palpably
"goes there." This is an incredibly fascinating Theology of the Body
work with room for endless discussion. I am still marveling at it in my mind.
There is so much to unpack.
GOD is all over this film. He is woven in everywhere as a character, as a force, as a
nemesis to be defeated or a deity to be trusted. He is in every cell of this
living, breathing film. This is profoundly religious art, not just because it
re-presents the vibrant, bygone faith of millions, but you can hear and feel
and see (three of the five senses) the filmmakers grappling with the postmodern
supposed "absence of God," and yet, the tenets of postmodernity are
not imposed or overlaid on this fine work. It is the perennial cri de coeur that is the heartbeat of "The
Frankenstein Chronicles." I would love to meet the minds behind this
filmic, metaphysical expedition that breaks through the fourth wall of pure virtuality
in a return to the body, the body, the body. And it is not a disgust or hatred
of the body or its so-called limitations, even the limitation of death. The
creators of FC know we can't be fully human without taking the body with us,
without being our bodies into the
next life, the afterlife, any life. They are dancing all around the ANSWER.
They are "not far from the kingdom of God." Well done, as the Brits
themselves say.
I wanted to scream at the screen: "See? You Brits know
how to do this! You know how to pray! (The Anglican nuns in "Call the
Midwife" praying and living from a faith-stance is also exquisite.) You
know how to ask all the right questions! You know how to be moral and memento mori and think about a judgment
and a final reckoning and that it's not just impolite and nasty to murder
people and cut them up and treat them like raw material for research--there's a
bigger, cosmically accountable dimension to it all! Perhaps FC is a form of England, "Mary's
Dowry," reclaiming its God-heritage, at least and for now in a
make-believe world? You may say I'm a dreamer. But I'm not the only one.
"A WORLD WITHOUT
GOD"
Over and over we hear this phrase in FC: "A world without
God," which has several layers. But of course, there is really no such
thing as a world without God, just as a fish dreaming of a world without water is
to dream of the impossible, or rather it means his certain death--something
very bad for him. "A world without God" is understood by the
believing characters as a horror.
Today, the English are such hardcore atheists. It seems their
atheism has morphed from the empiricists to the economists to the evolutionists
to the survivors of World War II. They are known for their brilliance, wit,
sarcasm, pessimism, "stiff upper lip," and a certain coldness--so
much so that the government of England has recently instituted a "Ministry
of Loneliness" for all the old people and others living in social
isolation! But isn't that the sweetest and most realistic thing ever? Calling
the ailment and problem by its actual name? Is that because England has a
female PM?
WE GOTTA GET RIGHT
BACK WHERE WE STARTED FROM
But England has a rich and beautiful Christian history--its
iterations and developments stretching back all the way to the first century
A.D. The English OWN the Bible. The Scriptures are still embedded everywhere in
their speech whether they even realize it or not. When I watch British
TV/films, the dialogue is often LITTERED with Scripture. So many common English
expressions come straight of out the beautiful and poetic language of the King
James Bible. The Bible is a touchstone for the true, good and beautiful in
English culture (along with Shakespeare who also drew on the Bible--a double
whammy). The British know they cannot just throw those words, English words--and their meanings--away.
England is enmeshed with God and His Word. She just needs to rediscover
Him--not by going backwards, but by going forwards, because the Word of God
stands forever, and there is much yet to be brought to fulfillment in it!
DEUS EST CARITAS
FC, like the original "Frankenstein" is a kind of
science fiction playground to examine God and human destiny. Frankenstein/FC is
no suicidal deathwish or fever dream of despair! It is a fierce desire and will
for life without end--but accomplished by disastrous human machinations. But
even by crossing lines and trashing ethics and breaking laws human and
divine...it will not succeed. It hath not the power. And not only that: Frankenstein/FC
is not just about humans attempting to overcome death, it's also human beings
attempting to usurp God. But the "god" these scientists aspire to be
is not even a benign God, but a despot and a puppeteer.
In the midst of all the destructive, desecrating horror, there
is tender love between lovers, spouses, parents and children. But is there also
the creeping sense (not on the part of the believing characters but on the part
of the storytellers) that perhaps that is the only love that exists (sans God)?
The film ends with the ocean. Does our main character lose
faith--and the mystery of something as large as the ocean is all that is left?
Does the ocean stand in for the "primordial soup" from which we all
supposedly sprang (and which "restores life" in the film)? Or is the
ocean the vastness of God Himself? Does the ocean signal that the search for
God continues?
"Lead me to the rock that is higher than I."
--Psalm 61
OTHER STUFF:
--Brave police, valiant priests, mad-scientist villains!
--FC is a long meditation. With lots of action.
--The moral and religious imagination is on full, full
display here.
--Abortion is not a good thing in FC. At one point, abortion
is correctly countered by a beautiful, intelligent young Christian woman who
disagrees and says: "Suffer the little children to come unto me."
--"Beware the beast." Yes, beware the beast
(Revelation 20:2). (There are occasional overtones of the occult leading up
to...?) What/who is "the beast"? The "resurrected"? The
devil? The monsters who tamper with human life (i.e., Nazi-scientist types)?
The body-snatcher(s)?
--"There is no God. As soon as you grasp that, anything
is possible."
--"They died for science. I make no apologies. I will
make any sacrifice for the work." [No, you murdered them for science.]
--"God will judge you for this!"
--At a certain point, a character is told that there is no
God. He is asked if he saw God in his "near-death" experience. He did
not, which seems to cause him some doubt. But let's remember the unnaturalness
of his "near-death" experience. (I hope I'm not being like Dan Quayle
talking to Murphy Brown here.) :)
--There is a twisty, twisted, almost-ending twist that could
have been the ending, but it is not. "Life" goes on. It gets a little
draggy at first at this point, with tons of dream sequences that we keep
getting jolted out of ourselves: Oopsy! It's a dream again! Now where the heck
were we in the story? This is the only flaw in FC, as well as some long,
silent, visually dark scenes where we're on a kind of "pause."
--One of the best screen portrayals of the afterlife/heaven:
"Tree Of Life"? "Heaven Is for Real"? "Miracles From
Heaven"? I can't recall. Shows the interwoven tapestry of people known and
barely known in our lives.
--Suggested book: The glorious and gloriously readable "Bede's
Ecclesiastical History of the English People."
Psalm 61
To the
choirmaster: with stringed instruments. Of David.
Hear my cry, O God,
listen to my prayer;
2 from the end of the earth I call to you
when my heart is faint.
Lead me to the rock
that is higher than I,
3 for you have been my refuge,
a strong tower against the enemy.
listen to my prayer;
2 from the end of the earth I call to you
when my heart is faint.
Lead me to the rock
that is higher than I,
3 for you have been my refuge,
a strong tower against the enemy.
4 Let
me dwell in your tent forever!
Let me take refuge under the shelter of your wings! Selah
5 For you, O God, have heard my vows;
you have given me the heritage of those who fear your name.
Let me take refuge under the shelter of your wings! Selah
5 For you, O God, have heard my vows;
you have given me the heritage of those who fear your name.
6 Prolong the
life of the king;
may his years endure to all generations!
7 May he be enthroned forever before God;
appoint steadfast love and faithfulness to watch over him!
may his years endure to all generations!
7 May he be enthroned forever before God;
appoint steadfast love and faithfulness to watch over him!
8 So
will I ever sing praises to your name,
as I perform my vows day after day.
as I perform my vows day after day.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)